This guide is part of our section on choosing a home health agency. It explains the two star ratings Medicare shows for home health agencies on Care Compare, and on our agency profiles. For how we display Medicare’s data, see our data methodology.

Two ratings, measuring different things

Two ratings, measuring different things
Quality of Patient Care rating Patient survey (HHCAHPS) rating
Based on 7 quality measures from patient assessments and Medicare claims 4 measures from a national survey of patients
Scale 1 to 5 stars, in half-star steps 1 to 5 whole stars
Minimum data At least 20 completed care episodes on at least 5 of the 7 measures, and at least 6 months of Medicare certification At least 40 completed surveys over four quarters
Updated Every quarter Every quarter

CMS updates both ratings with Care Compare’s quarterly refreshes in January, April, July and October. Each rating is calculated by CMS. Neither is made up of user reviews.

How the Quality of Patient Care rating is calculated

The 7 measures. CMS uses one measure about the process of care, five about patients’ improvement, and one about hospital use. In plain language, they show how often:

  1. The agency started patients’ care in a timely manner
  2. Patients got better at walking or moving around
  3. Patients got better at getting in and out of bed
  4. Patients got better at bathing
  5. Patients’ shortness of breath improved
  6. Patients got better at taking their drugs correctly by mouth
  7. Patients were admitted to the hospital for a potentially preventable condition while receiving home health care (for this one, lower is better)

CMS chose measures that apply to many patients, vary among agencies, are clinically relevant and stay stable over time. The outcome measures are risk-adjusted, which means CMS accounts for differences among patients, such as how ill they are when care starts.

The four steps. CMS’s methodology works like this:

  1. For each measure, all agencies nationally are sorted from lowest to highest score and split into 10 equal groups.
  2. Each group gets a starting rating from 0.5 to 5 in half-star steps, based on where it falls.
  3. If an agency’s score isn’t statistically different from the national median, its starting rating moves half a star toward the middle. Ratings already at 2.5 or 3 stay put.
  4. The adjusted ratings for all 7 measures are averaged, rounded to the nearest half star, and converted to a final rating from 1 to 5 stars.

That gives 9 possible ratings, with 3 stars in the middle. CMS says most agencies land in the middle because their average performance is close to their peers’, not because results are forced into a curve.

Whose care counts. Medicaid and Medicare Advantage patients are not excluded from the measures, except the hospitalization measure, which uses Original Medicare claims only. Each measure covers a 12-month period that ends months before the rating is published. Our methodology page lists the periods in the current release.

How the patient survey rating is calculated

The patient survey star rating comes from the Home Health Care Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (HHCAHPS), a standard survey about patients’ experience with their agency. Four survey measures get stars:

  • Care of patients
  • Communication between providers and patients
  • Specific care issues
  • Overall rating of care

A fifth survey question, whether patients would recommend the agency, is shown but gets no star. CMS says it mirrors the overall rating and its results weren’t stable enough to rate.

How stars are assigned. CMS turns each answer into a score from 0 to 100, adjusts it for differences in which patients answered, and averages it over four quarters. A statistical method then sorts agencies into 5 groups so scores within a group are as close as possible, and scores in different groups are as far apart as possible. Only whole stars are used. The summary star is the average of the four measure stars, rounded. An average of 3.5, for example, rounds up to 4 stars.

Why many agencies have no star rating

A blank rating usually means there wasn’t enough data, not that care was poor. CMS says agencies without a Quality of Patient Care rating are too small or too new, and that this doesn’t reflect on their quality. In the October 2024 data release, 65% of active agencies nationally got a rating.

Quality of Patient Care rating. A measure isn’t reported if the agency had fewer than 20 completed care episodes for it, because the result could reflect chance. The agency needs reportable data on 5 of the 7 measures and at least 6 months of certification. A small agency can have a rating one quarter and not the next. CMS’s footnotes for a missing rating include:

  • “The number of patient episodes for this measure is too small to report.”
  • “This measure currently does not have data or provider has been certified/recertified for less than 6 months.”

Patient survey rating. Agencies with fewer than 40 completed surveys over four quarters get no survey stars, though their survey percentages may still be shown. Survey footnotes include:

  • “Fewer than 70 patients completed the survey. Use the scores shown, if any, with caution as the number of surveys may be too low to accurately tell how an agency is doing.”
  • “No survey results are available for this period.”

When Medicare publishes no rating, our profiles show CMS’s reason where it gives one.

How often ratings change

CMS refreshes both ratings every quarter as older data drops off and newer data is added. Our snapshot is updated after Medicare’s quarterly releases.

For the patient survey, CMS re-estimates the score ranges for each star level each period. An agency can move to a different star level even if its score stays the same. CMS notes that survey scores are tightly bunched near the top, so a change of one percentage point can be enough to change the stars.

What star ratings don’t tell you

  • Ratings are relative. They show how an agency compares with others on selected measures. CMS says a rating of 1 or 2 stars doesn’t necessarily mean care is poor.
  • Not every area has a 4- or 5-star agency. CMS says some communities and even some states don’t.
  • The quality rating leaves things out. It does not include survey results or complaints. Inspection results are separate. See how to verify a Colorado home care agency license.
  • Ratings don’t confirm fit. They don’t tell you whether an agency serves your address, accepts your insurance, offers the services your doctor ordered, or can start when you need it.

CMS says star ratings shouldn’t be the only thing you use. It suggests also considering your own needs and preferences, other quality measures, references and past experiences with an agency.

Star ratings for Colorado agencies

What to do next

  1. Open your city page in our Colorado directory, such as Denver.
  2. For each agency, note both star ratings, or CMS’s reason if a rating is missing.
  3. Look at the individual measures that matter most to you, such as starting care on time.
  4. Check the agency’s inspection history and call with our questions to ask a home health agency.
  5. See how to choose a home health agency for the full process.

This guide is general information, not medical or legal advice. See our disclaimer.

Frequently asked questions

What does a 3-star rating mean?
For the Quality of Patient Care rating, 3 stars is the middle category. CMS says most agencies fall there and that a 3-star rating means the agency provides good quality of care. A rating above 3 stars means the agency did better than average compared with other agencies.
Why doesn't my agency have a star rating?
Usually because it is too small or too new. A Quality of Patient Care rating needs enough completed care episodes and at least 6 months of Medicare certification. A patient survey rating needs at least 40 completed surveys over four quarters. CMS says a missing rating doesn't reflect on an agency's quality.
Are Medicare star ratings the same as online reviews?
No. CMS calculates them from data agencies report about their patients' care and from a standard patient survey. CMS says they differ from consumer ratings for products like books, restaurants or hotels.
Why did an agency's rating change when its scores barely moved?
Ratings compare agencies with each other, and CMS recalculates them every quarter with newer data. For the patient survey, the score ranges for each star level are re-estimated, so the same score can earn a different number of stars.
Do the ratings include Medicaid and Medicare Advantage patients?
Mostly. CMS says Medicaid and Medicare Advantage patients are not excluded from the Quality of Patient Care measures, except the hospitalization measure, which uses Original Medicare claims only.

Sources

Primary sources checked for this guide on or before November 20, 2026. Rules and amounts can change; check the source for the latest version.

  1. Home Health Star Ratings — CMS.gov
  2. Quality of Patient Care Star Ratings Methodology (July 2024) — CMS.gov
  3. Frequently Asked Questions About the Quality of Patient Care Star Ratings (July 2024) — CMS.gov
  4. Fact Sheet: Quality of Patient Care Star Rating (July 2024) — CMS.gov
  5. Technical Notes for HHCAHPS Star Ratings — CMS.gov
  6. Patient Survey (HHCAHPS) Star Ratings: Frequently Asked Questions — CMS.gov
  7. HHQRP and HHVBP Data Dictionary, Version 14.0 (updated April 2026) — CMS (Provider Data Catalog)

This guide is general information from FamilyHomeHC, an independent site. It is not medical, legal or financial advice. Talk to your doctor about your care. In an emergency, call 911. Read our disclaimer.